Consumer Reports' Highest-Rated Diapers Aren't Kudos Or Huggies

Add Mom on Google:

Choosing a disposable diaper brand is a balancing act. On one hand, you don't want to break the bank because you're going to toss them pretty quickly. For the first three months, babies go through eight to 12 diapers daily. For the rest of the first year, that number shrinks only slightly, down to six to eight. Then again, since your baby is wearing diapers almost 24/7, parents want a gentle choice that also keeps laundry manageable by minimizing leaks. Surprisingly, when Consumer Reports compared popular brands in 2026, its highest-rated disposable diaper wasn't the time-tested Huggies or Pampers, or the up-and-comer Kudos. Instead, Target's store brand, Up & Up, took the top spot based on its excellent absorption speed and ability to keep babies' skin dry.

Up & Up wasn't always as highly rated – particularly back in 2017, when one reviewer on YouTube said, "Yes, they're cute. Yes, they're very soft, but for whatever reason, they keep leaking." But over the past decade, it appears the manufacturer has taken any criticisms to heart. In addition to the accolades from Consumer Reports, these diapers were also Wirecutter's top pick in 2026. Like Consumer Reports, Wirecutter praised Up & Up's absorption and also noted that the diapers were an impressive value. A pack costs about $27 for 162 newborn diapers (though prices may vary based on location). In contrast, a box of 144 Huggies diapers in the same size will set you back about $45 at Target.

Up & Up has across the board appeal

Like Wirecutter and Consumer Reports, Forbes also gave high marks to Up & Up, declaring the brand tops among value diapers. However, Forbes awarded Huggies as the best diaper overall. Then again, the methodology was different. While Forbes relied on results from parents who tried the diapers at home, Consumer Reports used a specific protocol in a controlled lab setting, and then replicated it for each brand. Surprisingly, while Wirecutter thought the Up & Up diapers fit smaller than other brands, Forbes' testers thought they had a more roomy fit. Across the board, several testers concluded Up & Up diapers out-absorbed Huggies.

Although absorption and dryness are essential for a diaper, Up & Up fans also appreciated the attention to detail. One test reviewer noted that the tabs' vibrant color eased diaper changes, while a customer review on the Target website noted that the tabs had the ideal amount of stick for a quiet and quick change — particularly important when babies are finally sleeping through the night.

The runner-up in Consumer Reports' testing was Bumbum Luxury Skincare disposable diapers. However, Bumbum has mixed reviews with parents. While Bumbum has plenty of fans, some users have been perplexed by the ingredients, especially aloe. Bumbum diapers are also far more expensive, selling at Target for about $20 for 82 diapers in size 1.

Recommended