Which Outgrown Kids' Shoes Are Worth Saving For A Sibling?

Add Mom on Google:

Kids grow fast: about 2 to 3 inches per year when they're preschoolers, then another 2.5 inches annually until around age 12. This pace makes hand-me-downs a real game-changer to save money. But while we wouldn't question passing down pants and shirts, what about footwear?

Whether it's clothes or shoes, condition is key. A pair of sweatpants with worn-out knees wouldn't get reused, and neither would a pair of grass-stained sneakers with holes. Unlike cozy sweats, a shoe's fit is more nuanced, since the footbed conforms to the kid's foot with repeated wear. If a sibling's feet are differently shaped, they may not be getting the proper support they need. This mismatch could even impact how a kid walks, especially if there's less arch support. In addition, sweaty feet and storage in a dark closet could make previously-worn shoes a hygiene concern (think mold, bacteria, and all things gross).

Even so, some pairs may be worth passing on, like shoes worn for a specific, infrequent purpose. Examples include snow and rain boots that hardly got used, as well as pre-walker baby shoes used for family photos. Some sandals and Croc-like shoes may be okay to pass down as well, but should be checked first. "If the shoe is in good condition and not overly worn, it should be fine to keep," Dr. Bob Baravarian, director of Docs Foot and Ankle in Los Angeles, explained to Mom exclusively. "If the shoe worked for the first child, there is no reason it can't work for the second child as long as the upper is still in good shape without holes and wear, and the sole has good tread."

Use this decision-making process to assess shoe wear

It can be more challenging to determine whether shoes are worth saving, since wear and tear isn't always obvious. Fortunately, Dr. Bob Baravarian supplied Mom with a checklist. "Check the sole of the shoe for wear and tread. Most shoes wear out on the back of the heel area and the ball of the foot," he explained. "If these are in good shape, you should be okay." In addition, place your hand flat against the front of the shoe and push, attempting to move the toe upward. If the shoe's sole is too bendable, it doesn't have adequate support (this is a good trick when shopping for new shoes as well).

As pairs are outgrown, assess their wear and sort accordingly, using the same system you'd use for kids' clothing hand-me-downs. For athletic shoes that aren't worth saving, consider recycling through brands like Nike or Kamik, or through a company like Got Sneakers.

For pairs that are worth saving, place them in a dedicated bin, labeled as "hand-me-downs" or with the younger sibling's name. As that child grows, you can take a second look at any shoes in the bin and see if time has changed your perspective on reusing them. If the shoes are in good shape but you don't have a younger kid to pass them on to, you might be able to donate them, either to a local thrift store in your area or through a wider-scale program like Soles 4 Souls.

Recommended